Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees: Rite of Spring

I recently borrowed this book from my local library. Libraries rule!

Rite of Spring is a continuation of the series Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees, which I read and reviewed last year. In this book we flash forward eight years into the 1990s and the advent of the internet becoming commonplace in homes. With this new technology comes different ways to communicate and share/search for information, which transforms small town living and also begins to complicate Samantha's life. It turns out that people searching for murder victims can track clues and share info on message boards, which brings Monica, a persistent and determined duck, to town to figure out what happened to her brother Daniel, who was one of Samantha's victims.

Monica's momentum is formidable, which makes it compelling to see how Samantha deals with her. This book has just as many twists and turns as the original series, with Samantha trying to stay ahead of her pursuer(s) while pretending to befriend and assist them. Secretly, she is also planning a pretty vicious response of her own. Additionally, her past is explored and the origins of her murderous ways are revealed (to the reader anyhow). 

The artwork is charmingly disturbing in how it uses the cuteness of funny animals to embody horror movie tropes. The gory bits are more shocking in their realism when juxtaposed with the general picture book animal qualities. Overall, I was impressed by how well plotted and creepy this book is, and the way it ends promises more dreadful deeds to come, which I will eagerly await.

Patrick Horvath wrote and drew this series, with lettering by Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou. Horvath has written and directed a number of movies, and beyond this debut series of his he also is writing the Archie in Hell mini-series. Otsmane-Elhaou has lettered books for many different publishers and also was a co-editor of PanelxPanel, an excellent, Eisner Award-winning web journal about comics. Horvath speaks about this follow-up story arc and future installments in this interview.

The reviews I have read of this book have been positive, though some point out the let-down that can come with a sequel. David Brooke wrote that it "successfully builds on the original series with a compelling new protagonist, emotional depth, and chilling visuals." Ian Keogh called it "very readable, but not as strong as the first outing." Greg Burgas wrote about having "serial killer fatigue" in general but still found it to be "a fairly worthwhile comic."

Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees: Rite of Spring was published by IDW, and they offer more info about it here. This book is not for kids.

Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees

I read this series on the Global Comix app, and it's also now available in a handy trade paperback. Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees is a title that has been very popular at my local comic shop, and I have been pretty curious what all the excitement was about. It's a beautifully drawn book, with characters who are depicted as anthropomorphic animals a la Richard Scarry's Busytown but who act in much darker ways. In my description below, I am purposefully being vague, because I do not want to give too much away.

The main character is Samantha Strong, a bear who runs the local hardware store in the sleepy town of Woodbrook and who engages in some pretty vicious deeds on the sly. When some of the locals get murdered, the ensuing investigations threaten her secrets, so she decides to take matters in her own hands to find the culprit.

Woodbrook is full of a vast array of inhabitants, including dogs, birds, mice, pigs, goats,cats, foxes, raccoons, turtles, and more. They are all panic-stricken by the murder and their small town is gripped by terror. Part of what is engaging about this book is seeing a sort of crime procedural plot occur in this picture book setting, but the mystery elements are well-plotted, and there are enough suspects and plot twists to make things interesting. Because of the dark subject matter, I suggest this book for more mature readers who can deal with gruesome murder, but there is also a touch of whimsy that comes with the watercolor artwork that sets this series apart. I found it a very entertaining and sumptuous reading experience.

Patrick Horvath wrote and drew this series, with lettering by Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou. Horvath has written and directed a number of movies, and this is his debut comics work. Otsmane-Elhaou has lettered books for many different publishers and also was a co-editor of PanelxPanel, an excellent, Eisner Award-winning web journal about comics. Horvath speaks about his inspirations and work on BTTWNS in this interview.

All of the reviews I have read about this collection have been positive. Publishers Weekly wrote, "Horvath’s charming picture-book artwork, rendered in bright painterly strokes and packed with visual detail, makes the gruesome subject matter all the more disturbing." Kate called it "one of the most unique graphic novel experiences I’ve had this year." Zack Quaintance concluded, "It all makes for a great spooky season read, and a fun addition to your comics bookshelf from a cartoonist whose work definitely bears following into the future."

Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees was published by IDW, and they offer more information about it here. For those who want more, a sequel series, Beneath the Trees Where Nobody Sees: Rite of Spring, which is set a decade after this series, is currently being published.