Derf Backderf, author of the graphic novels Kent State and My Friend Dahmer, is an artist whose work is must-read for me. His newest book The Dissidents was recently published, and before I got my hard copy I borrowed it from my local library (LIBRARIES RULE!). It follows the life and exploits of Joe Hertle, a fictional cartoonist in the 1910s who finds himself caught up in a maelstrom of events. He is a socialist who works for a newspaper, relegated to drawing puzzle pages but yearning to be a political cartoonist. Specifically he aspires to draw for a socialist magazine called The Masses, which was a real publication that showcased some of the strongest artists and most vocal critics of the day. Joe eventually gets to work with several of the artists who actually worked on that magazine, and this book does an excellent job showcasing some of them and their works in the course of setting the context for this tale.
Joe's aspirations meet up with harsh reality as World War I rages on and the Russian Revolution gets waged. President Wilson introduced the Espionage and Sedition Acts. These acts seriously curtail what can be published, with criminal sentences for works considered anti-American. The Masses ceases publication and many of the artists either flee the country or go into hiding. As a potential radical, Joe loses his job at the newspaper as well. To make matters worse, there is also a group called the American Protective League that was acting to neutralize German sympathizers and others it deemed un-American, often violently and with the covert approval of the Bureau of Investigation (precursor to the FBI). The APL threatens Hertle's family, who are of German descent, which further complicates and troubles his life.
I am not capturing all of the nuances in this book, as there are a great many other things going on as well. It works as a suspense tale and a historical overview. It is a snapshot of a complicated, troubled time that tries to give a clear picture of many prominent figures. I think its scope is ambitious and impressive, and I took away much from reading this book, also struck by eerie similarities to current events in the USA.
Moreover I think that Derf's artwork might be better than ever. He definitely rose to the occasion in terms of rendering the people and art of the day, not to mention all of the buildings and architecture. I also liked his occasional use of color to liven up the otherwise black and white imagery. He is clearly passionate about the time period and these artists, and his enthusiasm in telling these tales is palpable.
All of the reviews I have read about it have been positive. Jim Falcone described it as "a solid historical fiction that I wish could’ve quit it with the fiction." Kirkus Reviews called it "a compelling historical exploration of the bounds and consequences of graphic dissent." Kerry Vineberg wrote, "The Dissidents is essential reading for anyone interested in building a better world."
The Dissidents was published by Abrams ComicArts, and they offer more information about it here.















